When Acoustic Won't Cut It: How to Choose a Good Electronic Keyboard for Aspiring Pianists
- adelaidemusicllc
- Jul 16
- 3 min read
As a piano teacher, I've seen it all. I've taught lessons in homes with gorgeous full-size Yamaha grands and and homes with tiny plastic keyboards complete with light-up keys. For families who don't want to break the bank but want to invest in their child a question I often get is "what kind of piano should I get?". Is it worth it to invest in a $10,000 baby grand? Or will dad's portable keyboard from the 80's do?
While nothing beats the rich sound and touch of a well-maintained acoustic instrument, the reality is that it’s not the best fit for every family. And that’s okay!
If you live in a small home, apartment, or condo—or you’re dealing with sound concerns, budget limitations, or inherited pianos in poor condition—an electronic keyboard can be a fantastic choice for your piano student. In fact, choosing the right keyboard can lead to more productive practice and a better playing experience than an out-of-tune or poorly regulated acoustic upright.
If you're wanting to invest in your child's musical future but don't know where do start, here’s a great guide on what to look for when buying your first digital piano—and a few options I recommend at various price points.
✅ What Makes a Good Electronic Keyboard?
Not all keyboards are created equal! Here are the three most important features to look for:
1. A Reputable Brand
Stick with trusted manufacturers like Yamaha, Roland, Kawai, Casio, or Korg. These companies have a long-standing reputation for producing realistic digital pianos with reliable action and sound.
2. 88 Keys
A full-sized keyboard has 88 keys, just like an acoustic piano. Some smaller models can work for very young beginners or tight spaces, but your student will eventually need all 88 keys to develop proper technique and hand range.
💡 Tip: If you must go smaller due to space, look for at least 61 touch-sensitive keys as a temporary solution.
3. Weighted Keys
This is non-negotiable. Weighted or "hammer action" keys simulate the feel of an acoustic piano. They help students build proper finger strength and control—skills that simply don't develop on springy, plastic-feeling keys.
🎧 Other Must-Haves:
✅ A Sustain Pedal
Look for a keyboard that includes a proper sustain pedal—preferably one that mimics the feel and resistance of a real piano pedal (not the plastic square kind that slides all over the floor!). You can always purchase a better pedal separately if needed (I always recommend Yamaha pedals).
✅ Proper Height Setup
Just as important as the keyboard itself is how it's set up. The keys should sit about 28.5 to 30 inches high (roughly the same height as an acoustic piano), and your child’s elbows should be level with the keys when seated.Invest in an adjustable bench and stand if needed—it really makes a difference in posture and hand position.
🎹 My Keyboard Recommendations
If you are looking for a keyboard that meets these criteria, look no further! Here are three great options at different price points, each with 88 weighted keys and solid reputations. I’ve included affiliate links, so if you choose to purchase through them, it supports my studio at no extra cost to you! Keep in mind that you may need to purchase certain accessories separately, such as pedal, stand, and bench.
💰 Budget Option: Alesis Recital Pro
Great for beginners who want fully weighted keys without breaking the bank.
88 hammer-action keys
Built-in speakers + headphone jack
Lightweight and portable
💡 Mid-Range Favorite: Yamaha P-125
This is the one I have in my home studio. Excellent value with realistic feel and sound quality.
Graded hammer action
USB/MIDI connection
Optional furniture stand available
🎵 Premium Pick: Roland FP-30X
A beautiful, expressive keyboard perfect for serious students or long-term use.
Exceptional key feel with PHA-4 action
Bluetooth MIDI/audio support
Compact and stylish design
🎶 Final Thoughts
A good keyboard can make all the difference in your child’s musical development. It’s not just about convenience—it’s about giving them a tool that feels good, sounds great, and supports their growth as a musician. Whether you're just starting out or upgrading from a beginner model, I hope this guide helps you choose the right fit for your family.
Looking for lessons? Adelaide Music LLC may be the right fit for you! We offer free trial lessons when you reach out online - sign up today!
This post was made with the help of chatgpt.
Comments